|
|
此文章由 ellepopo 原创或转贴，不代表本站立场和观点，版权归 oursteps.com.au 和作者 ellepopo 所有！转贴必须注明作者、出处和本声明，并保持内容完整
本帖最后由 ellepopo 于 2013-7-19 13:19 编辑
1 为了AL而成立trust, 就是画蛇添足。大多数情况就是没必要；
From where did you see I ask people to set up a trust just for Associate lease? I'm telling people a family trust can be treated as associate of the employee.
The beauty of associate lease is when the associate is a family trust. The salary trasnfer effect can be maximised, especially for the family with parent migrants.
这不是你的原话么？ 你虽然没有明说，但是是有INDICATION 的；
2 GST一般annual gross income 少于75k 都不建议register for GST, 为什么？ create more fees for accountants, 还有lease 结束ATO 一定会追GST的。100%
Same as above, from where did you see I ask people to register GST just for associate lease. I'm saying if you register then you can claim GST back. BTW, you keep talking fee to the accountants, please, read what I said: if the saving outweight the extra fee, worthy of doing. If you don't care $1000 or more saving each year, just walk away. If you don't understand how FBT works, just keep quite.
原帖由 easter 于 2012-5-23 14:28 发表
一般来讲用 associate lease 你就没有input tax credit
这个是corporate contribution的10%， 也不是很小的数字
注册GST便是，总不能要省税又怕麻烦的。
这也是你的原话，就是因为大家都想省钱，我的建议是如果你把省的钱和你要额外花费的钱来比较如果相差不过，意义不大，而且本身GST就是一个很要提前考虑的问题，你轻描淡写的说一句那就注册GST吧，有可能LZ要为此多支付好几千块，和省下的钱相比，你觉得有意义吗？而且你自己对GST 的认识也是很浅薄的，只会做FBT是不能做一个好的TAX ADVISER的。
3 AL 的关键是associate 的tax position。non resident for tax purpose-has to pay non resident tax rate for income. Tax resident - has to disclose overseas income; 一般的建议都是要先找专业人士咨询，才能进行下一步。
You get even more bullshit now. When did I say you can associate lease with a non tax resident?
我认为LZ 的情况就是应该要考虑是不是要成为tax resident, 也可以是part year tax resident, 专业人士都会建议在做LEASE 之前做一个TAX PLAN, 这是很必须，因为每个人的财务状况不一样，你直接跳过这一步，就说明你没有这方面的经验，或者你只是想卖弄你FBT的学识而已；
4 从税局2年前更改statutory method 的rate 就可以知道这一块本身就是有漏洞的，现在堵上了
That's why I say must be someone like you behind the change, clearly you don't understand the tax law or even any law, have you seen any law without amendment or uncertainty? Talk to those who have to travel 40,000 km a year to get to work, talk to those who count on some tax saving for some food on their table. Tell them you think the change of law is correct.
你怎么不说是为了省钱去买几个名牌包包呢？做AL的都是税率高的人才有动力做， 不然成本和回报不成正比，就算是每年上班来回超过40k公里的，那也是上班啊，每个人上班坐车要付费，开车要付油费，有什么不妥吗？如果都是work related travel, 根本就是不需要通过salary sacrifice 来做这些无谓的事情，也根本就没有FBT tax liability.
5 你的lease agreement 是你的版权吗，不是最好删了
Don't you worry about that, I have different version for work and the one I gave people is my own IP. I'm way more professinal than you thought.
I think you are more show off than be professional, do you have PI insurance to cove all your 'tax advice' and all the template you provided to the public?
6 你的专长是FBT，如果自己不是100% 有把握的，最好不要advise
Same comments to you, you'd better keep quite about FBT.
你不觉得你作为40多的大男人说这话很粗鲁吗? I don't want to and I would never provide any tax advice to any body in this scenario, because I don't want to take any risk. Since your knowledge in Income tax, GST is very limited, you can not only advise people in FBT without reminding people to seek professional tax advice in other area.
7 感谢你让我借此机会好好研究了AL，no point to argue any more!
You are welcome for technical debate.
你对持有不同意见的人的态度就是冷嘲加熱讽， 我想不会有人再愿意和你交流了。
8 BTW, you seems to come to the wrong place, you have too many shit!!! |
|
行路版活动－吃货们的足迹! ❤美食在香港～ 另类人生，体验不一样的香港生活！❤ (2013-5-22) Kittymeow 
发表于 2012-5-18 15:43
